Skip to main content

Research Update: Latest Analysis of COVID-19 Impact on Houston Economy

Published Mar 20, 2020 by Patrick Jankowski

Downtown for Fortune 500

As recently as early March, many economists believed (or perhaps hoped) that if the Federal Reserve cut interest rates and Congress enacted a large fiscal stimulus package, the U.S. could avoid a recession. Two weeks later, interest rates are near zero and Washington is working to inject $1 trillion into the U.S. economy. Unfortunately, that’s all too late. The U.S. is already in a recession, and so is Houston.

Conventional wisdom holds that the U.S. is in a recession when the nation has logged two or more consecutive quarters of declining gross domestic product (GDP). If we stuck with that definition, we’d have to wait until July or October to determine if the U.S. were in a recession. 

The Business Cycle Dating Committee (yes, there is such an organization) of the National Bureau for Economic Research (NBER) embraces a broader definition. The committee looks for a “significant decline in economic activity spread across the economy, lasting more than a few months, normally visible in real GDP, income, employment, industrial production, and wholesale-retail sales.” The official reports on those metrics have begun to trickle out, but one can surmise from media reports that a “significant decline” is already occurring. No need to wait for a committee of experts to pronounce the U.S. is in a recession. The Partnership recognizes that we’re in one.

But, what do the vast majority of economists say?

Every month, the Wall Street Journal asks a panel of 70 or more prominent economists when they expected the next recession. In January, only 10.8 percent of respondents expected one this year. In February, 58.5 percent expected a recession within the next nine months, with 41.5 percent expecting a recession to start in Q2. Those results were gathered before the coronavirus began shutting down restaurants, bars, sporting events and stores. Given the trajectory of recent events, the April survey will likely show the vast majority of the panel believes the U.S. is in a recession.

How bad will it get in 2020? 

•    Moody’s Analytics sees the U.S. economy contracting 1.6 percent in Q1 and 2.5 percent in Q2 before picking up in the second half of the year and exceeding three percent growth in 2021.
•    J.P. Morgan expects GDP to contract two percent in Q1 and three percent in Q2 before bouncing back in Q3.
•    Goldman Sachs sees the economy flat in Q1, contracting five percent in Q2, then growth exceeding three percent in the second half of the year.
•    Markit expects consumer spending to decline through June and the economy to remain in a slump through the end of the year. GDP will contact 5.4 percent in Q2 and 1.9 percent over Q3 and Q4.  IHS forecasts U.S. GDP to grow only 0.8 percent in ’21.

The Partnership is concerned that all the above forecasts, except for IHS market, may be overly optimistic.  Weak global growth, declines in the energy sector, shattered consumer confidence, and a wave of credit defaults and bankruptcies will weigh on the recovery.

What does this mean for Houston?

Any time the U.S. tumbles into a recession, Houston gets bruised and battered. This time Houston’s injuries will be more than superficial.  As noted in March’s Houston: the Economy at a Glance, Russia and Saudi Arabia are dueling over who will control global oil markets. Houston is caught in the crossfire. The collapse in oil prices (trading near $24 a barrel, less than half February’s level) will force another restructuring of Houston’s energy sector, the second in the past six years. Houstonians should anticipate a new round of layoffs and bankruptcies. These losses will be compounded by those brought on by the U.S. recession. 

Houstonians like to embrace the notion that their metro was among the last to enter the Great Recession and was among the first to exit. That’s not going to be the case this time. All three pillars of Houston’s economy—energy, global trade and the U.S. economy—are tottering. The next 12 to 18 months will likely be very rough for Houston.

Visit the Partnership's COVID-19 Resource page for updates, guidance for employers and more information. And sign up for daily email alerts from the Partnership as the situation develops. 

Related News

Economic Development

How Amazon's Strategic Procurement Drives Inclusive Growth

11/20/24
Amazon’s leadership in supplier diversity has positioned the corporation for success while driving inclusive economic growth. Kennedy Oates, Partnership Board Member and Vice President of Global Procurement at Amazon, shared insights and best practices at the Greater Houston Partnership’s One Houston Together Fall Chief Procurement Officers (CPO) Convening.  Oates discussed how Amazon has grown its supplier diversity efforts by ensuring the value proposition of intentional inclusion of underrepresented businesses is communicated at every level. According to Amazon’s 2023 Sustainability Report, the company’s global supplier diversity and inclusion (SDI) program is estimated to have supported over 30,000 U.S. jobs and generated approximately $2.8 billion in wages earned from Amazon's certified U.S. Tier 1 supplier diversity spend.  In 2023, Amazon was inducted into the Billion Dollar Roundtable, a non-profit organization comprised of U.S. corporations that each spend $1 billion or more annually on a Tier 1 basis with diverse suppliers. These diverse-owned businesses comprise majority owners who identify as minorities, women, veterans, disabled and LGBTQ.  Oates stated that achieving this milestone required a deliberate approach, built on a clear vision, a targeted strategy, and an empowered team dedicated to executing these goals. By embedding supplier diversity into Amazon’s core procurement practices, they’ve fostered a sustainable and inclusive growth model that supports both the company’s goals and the success of diverse suppliers. Key Takeaways from CPO Convening Supplier Diversity as a Strategic Value Proposition Oates emphasized the importance of viewing supplier diversity as more than just an initiative—highlighting the long-term value diverse suppliers bring to a company and its surrounding communities. Through its global SDI strategy, Amazon measures impact through jobs supported, wages earned and economic output generated. “Given our reach and scale, Amazon has a greater responsibility.” – Kennedy Oates, VP of Global Procurement, Amazon Vision-Driven Goals with Clear Strategies For Amazon, supplier diversity goals go beyond simple statements. Oates stressed the importance of crafting a well-defined vision, supported by actionable strategies to advance supplier diversity objectives. This approach includes setting clear, market-specific spending targets, identifying procurement categories that have greater opportunity based passed success, and building relationships with suppliers by understanding their needs and their customers’ needs. In addition, internal teams should have collaborative discussions on supplier diversity across the entire business rather than in silos.   Partnering with Companies at Every Level “Every large company was once small.” – Kennedy Oates, VP of Global Procurement, Amazon Amazon is redefining procurement by challenging the perception that only large companies can serve large corporations. Its approach embraces partnerships with businesses of all sizes, embedding supplier diversity as a core element of its supply chain. While direct spending with certified Tier 1 diverse suppliers is central to Amazon’s SDI program, the company further amplifies its impact by encouraging Tier 1 suppliers to include diverse Tier 2 businesses in their procurement processes. For example, Amazon sets specific spend targets in contracts with Tier 1 suppliers to use Disadvantaged Business Enterprises, creating a positive ripple effect that brings opportunities to underrepresented companies deeper in the supply chain. To learn more about the Partnership’s Supplier Diversity workstream, contact LaTanya Flix.
Read More
Economic Development

Geothermal Startup Sage Geosystems Highlights Potential for New Energy in Houston

11/12/24
Long known as the energy capital of the world, Houston is proving its merit as the industry embraces an all-inclusive approach to energy sources. Beyond the wealth of oil and gas capital, Houston has become a landing spot for numerous solar, wind and battery storage investments. Companies like Fluence Energy, Renewable Parts and Solar Plus have chosen Houston for its manufacturing of innovative energy products. Geothermal Energy: An Untapped Resource Geothermal energy, often unsung in the new energy landscape, can be found beneath our feet, harnessing the power of heat lying underground. In conventional geothermal power plants, wells are drilled into geothermal reservoirs to access hot water or steam, which is then brought to the surface. This steam is used to drive turbines that generate electricity. Sage Geosystems is changing that by pursuing geothermal potential in rock that is hot but doesn't have the large volumes of water to bring the heat to the surface. Hot, dry rock enables geothermal power generation in many more places as the geology is more prevalent which enables geothermal to now be deployable almost anywhere in the world. Sage Geosystems: Leading Geothermal Innovation Houston is seeing its chance to make a mark with geothermal thanks to companies like Sage Geosystems, founded in 2020 with its headquarters near Bush Intercontinental Airport. Sage works to build the technology that makes this renewable energy a greater force in the worldwide energy transition, engaged in contracts and partnerships with local energy providers, major government agencies like the U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) and hyper-scalers like Meta Platforms. On the public utility side, the company recently partnered with the San Miguel Electric Cooperative to build the first geopressured geothermal system. The technology used can be paired with solar and/or wind to convert these intermittent clean energy sources to 24-hour power generation, or it can be used to move these clean energy sources from a time of day when the demand is low to a time of day when the demand is high, stabilizing the utility grid and helping mitigate the issue of blackouts and brownouts. The facility will be commissioned in December. Sage has three ongoing projects with the DOD. The U.S. Air Force recently provided Sage with $1.9 million in Tactical Funding Increase (TACFI) funding to perform a geothermal demonstration with electricity generation, which will take place in Sage's test well in Starr County, Texas with a targeted completion date of Q3/Q4 2025.  The Defense Innovation Unit (DIU) has funded two geothermal feasibility studies for the U.S. Army installation of Fort Bliss in El Paso and the Naval Air Station CC in Corpus Christi. Sage is performing these feasibility studies with the University of Texas Bureau of Economic Geology. The intent of these studies is to evaluate the technical and economic feasibility of geothermal system installations using Sage's Geopressured Geothermal System (GGS) technology at these two DOD installations. Collaboration Powers Innovation in Houston As evidenced by the above, collaboration plays a central role in the growth of Sage Geosystems. The company has not only partnered with utility companies and major governmental institutions, but also collaborated with the Rice Alliance for Technology and the Greater Houston Partnership to facilitate work with institutions of higher learning like the University of Houston and Rice, venture capital firms, and established energy corporations such as ABB, Chesapeake (now Expand Energy), Nabors, and Geolog. This sense of collaboration is one of the many reasons Sage Geosystems has thrived in Houston, along with the infrastructure, talent and innovative spirit that propels local companies to success. The Houston Advantage for Energy Startups “While Texas is the top energy state in the U.S., Houston is the heart. Houston provides not only access to the O&G industry, but also many utilities and others interested and/or working in energy...The Houston energy ecosystem and the benefits described above will continue to be critical in this scale-up plan." - Sage Geosystems CEO Cindy Taff Looking ahead, Sage is building its first commercial energy storage facility and will be performing a geothermal power generation demonstration with the U.S. Air Force in 2025.  Sage sees Houston as the best place to scale in Texas and throughout the world. "Geothermal energy represents a transformative opportunity for Houston as it further strengthens our position as the global energy capital. Sage Geosystems' innovative approach to harnessing geothermal resources exemplifies the spirit of collaboration, innovation, and commitment to sustainability that defines our region’s energy leadership.” - Partnership Senior Vice President of Economic Development Craig Rhodes  For any new energy startups looking to establish themselves, Taff recommends leveraging Houston’s many assets for future success. “Tap into existing knowledge that can be transferred to clean tech and partner with companies that know where to find the skills needed to give your startup a leg up,” Taff said. “Join local incubators like Rice Alliance for Technology and the Houston Technology Center and others, leverage Greater Houston Partnership and Greentown Labs for networking, collaborate with Rice University and University of Houston, and take advantage of Texas' business-friendly regulatory environment.” Sage Geosystems is a prime example of how energy startups use Houston’s assets as a springboard to meet their potential, along with renowned innovators such as Syzygy Plasmonics, Cemvita Factory, and Fervo Energy. Learn more about the business opportunities within Houston's energy industry and its all-inclusive energy ecosystem.   
Read More

Related Events

Economic Development

Houston Region Economic Outlook

Tickets now on sale! Featuring economists and industry leaders, the Houston Region Economic Outlook takes a close look at the core industries driving job growth and economic indicators measuring the…

Learn More
Learn More
Executive Partners